4.3 WebPageTest
The deepest look at what actually happened.
webpagetest.org
WebPageTest tests from real devices in real locations and gives you far more detail than any other tool.
Use it when you know the page is slow and need to know why.
What it gives you
The waterfall. Every request, when it started, what it blocked on, how long each phase took. Request-ordering problems are obvious here in a way a score never shows — you can see the font that waited for the stylesheet that waited for the redirect.
The filmstrip. Screenshots at intervals through the load, so you can see exactly what the user saw and when. Pairs well with the waterfall: find the frame where content appears, then look at what finished just before it.
Connection view. DNS, TCP and TLS time per host — the clearest way to see what extra origins cost you.
Real devices and locations. Test from Mumbai on a real mid-range Android, rather than simulating it.
Worth knowing
First view versus repeat view. It tests both by default. The repeat view shows whether your cache headers work — a repeat view that re-downloads everything is a caching bug.
Test more than once. Network conditions vary. Run three and compare.
The interface is dense and dated, but nothing else shows you as much.